I have read all of Elin Hilderbrand's books and have enjoyed them thoroughly. However, this book was utterly depressing. The subject matter is depressing - car accident with four highschool student, one dies, others suffering as a result. The parents of all the teenagers suffer. There can't be any happy resolution to this. I'm really surprised by Hilderbrand's approach. She's tackled difficult subject matter in other books and offered an optimist perspective. There is no optimism here. Pass on this.

The book was okay – but not one of my favorites.

Hilderbrand is one of my favorite authors... however, I was surprisingly disappointed with this book. I had to force myself to keep reading as it failed to hold my interest. The story was rather stagnant and included a little too much high school drama.

can't wait to see it!

Elin Hiderbrand writes good, easy summery fiction. Although after reading all her books, they are getting too formula driven-But I still want to go to Nantucket!

Great read... kept me turning the pages!

I agree great summer read.

Great summer read! Elin Hilderbrand is great at writing complex realistic characters while leaving the reader with hope, not sap.